There's a ton of non accounted variables in this question. It's vague and incomplete, so this is excluding health, porn habits, vitamin, sleep, etc. Sexual market place values would say that if you're funding less attractive women as attractive or you're "over valuing" them it would dictate you don't have enough good women in your life. Rarity increases value, it means lower quality products are higher in value. A crappy car is a great find if nobody you know has a car.

Alternatively there's something to be said for this also being used as a buffer. Your mind is OK being rejected by lower value mates as opposed to risking rejection with what you might value as a higher value mate. There's more at stake and it reflects more upon you as a person. See The Rational Male and it's reference to psychological buffers